Hitchens on Solzhenitsyn: “as if”

Some good thoughts on Alexander Solzhenitsyn by Christopher Hitchens, fascinating both as a tribute to Solzhenitsyn and as a window into Hitchens’ own obsessions and prejudices, particularly as regards Christianity (which is allowed to take none of the credit for Solzhenitsyn’s good qualities, but plenty of the blame for his faults).

Hitchens summarises Solzhenitsyn’s “fortitude” as follows:

The simplest way of phrasing it is to say that Solzhenitsyn lived “as if.” Barely deigning to notice the sniggering, pick-nose bullies who followed him and harassed him, he carried on “as if” he were a free citizen, “as if” he had the right to study his own country’s history, “as if” there were such a thing as human dignity.

Hitchens does not seem to notice (or is unwilling to admit) that Solzhenitsyn’s Christian faith may have been what enabled him to live in this way; that he may not have been living simply “as if” he had freedom and dignity, but with confidence that he actually did possess those things, even only by faith and not by sight.

Of course, Hitchens is rather more willing to invoke Christianity as being to blame for Solzhenitsyn’s more “ayatollahlike” qualities:

As time went by, he metamorphosed more and more into a classic Russian Orthodox chauvinist, whose work became more wordy and propagandistic and—shall we be polite?—idiosyncratic with every passing year.

Hitchens suggests that “the resulting mixture of attitudes and prejudices puts one in mind more of Dostoyevsky than of Tolstoy”. (That’s a bad thing?)

Still, Hitchens’ last word is more generous:

Dostoyevsky even at his most chauvinistic was worth a hundred Mikhail Sholokhovs or Maxim Gorkys, and Solzhenitsyn set a new standard for the courage by which a Russian author could confront the permafrost of the Russian system.

This entry was posted in Atheism, Books, Eastern Orthodoxy. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Hitchens on Solzhenitsyn: “as if”

  1. Thomas says:

    Ah, yes, Tolstoy, the sniggering moralist who despised women and sex and most other merely human matters, thought himself a messiah of sorts, and held all art in contempt even as he created two or three masterpieces. He was not, of course, Orthodox, but, hey, that’s no problem.

  2. John H says:

    …Tolstoy, the sniggering moralist…

    Makes you wonder what on earth Hitchens sees in him…

  3. Mack Ramer says:

    Excellent post, John. Solzhenitsyn’s life story, like those of Fr. Arseny, Fr. Jean Bernard, or Dietrich Bonhoeffer, stands as a great testament to the power of prayer and Christian faith over the godless, statist monstrosities of the 20th century.

  4. Josh S says:

    I’m sure all the faults of Communism were due to somehow to Christianity as well.

  5. John H says:

    Josh: if you think you’re joking, you’ve obviously never heard an atheist apologist explain earnestly that Stalin only turned out the way he did because he started out as an Orthodox seminarian…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s