Fit to be tied

Sam Leith engages with the current hot topic gripping the nation: is it all over for the tie?

He points out that even middle-aged, middle-class gatherings are now sublimely unconcerned at the sight of a tieless man in a relatively formal context (such as when Leith forgot to wear a tie when interviewing Seamus Heaney at a recent literary festival). Ten years ago the reaction would have been far different (I recall the BBC receiving complaints during the 1991 Gulf War, after a correspondent out in the baking heat of the Kuwaiti desert dared to appear on TV without a jacket and tie.)

Leith concludes:

The role the tie plays is symbolic rather than practical. It is a sign – and its meaning is, as Saussure put it, “arbitrary”. It advertised – at first – membership of the community of respectable men in the public sphere.

More recently, as it has become less general, it has advertised a certain formality of occasion.

My point is that if people no longer notice – if the sign “tie” is now in free variation with “no tie” – its symbolic value, and hence its actual value, has disappeared. Collared shirt vs T-shirt still has a certain force. Tie vs no tie, vanishingly so.

All good clean fun. Though I suspect Leith may be trying to maximise the spluttering outrage among Telegraph readers: “Not only does this man Leith not want to wear a tie, but then he starts quoting fancypants foreign ‘intellectuals’ (dread word!) in support of his degenerate leftist nonsense.”

FWIW, your correspondent is currently sitting – in the offices of a professional firm in a town that is a byword for conservatism – tieless, but with one in my pocket, just in case a client turns up…

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Culture. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Fit to be tied

  1. Well, I’m an ecosocialist member of the anti-tie vanguard, and find I can usually get from one end of a calendar year to another without wearing one. I’ve gone tieless to a funeral, to weddings (including my own) and to my last few job interviews (though I work in a profession which accommodates this). The last time I wore a tie was in court, I think. Why should men wear something so uncomfortable, and which can limit the supply of blood flow to the brain? No, into the dustbin of history with it, and then – with clever Mr G.B. Shaw of London – let us raise a glass of carrot juice to Rational Dress.

  2. John H says:

    Not to menshun speling reeform.

  3. The Scylding says:

    As being a geologist, and as having been a farmer, ties are generally anathema….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s